Communication Technology  

 

 

 

Cellular Vs WiFi

Cellular communication and WiFi communication are two prevalent technologies for wireless communication, each with distinct characteristics and applications. Cellular communication excels in providing broad, continuous coverage and is essential for mobile and wide-area applications. In contrast, WiFi offers high-speed, cost-effective connectivity within a limited range, ideal for stationary or limited-mobility use. Both technologies continue to evolve, offering improved speed, security, and functionality. Followings are some of the highlevel comparison between Cellular and WiFi.

  • Technology Basis:
    • Cellular Communication: Operates on a wide range of frequencies allocated for cellular networks. It uses a cellular network architecture where the coverage area is divided into small geographic areas called cells. Each cell is served by a base station.
    • WiFi Communication: Uses IEEE 802.11 standards and operates mainly on two frequency bands: 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz. Unlike cellular networks, WiFi is based on a local area network (LAN) design, where a wireless router provides a connection within a short range.
  • Range and Coverage:
    • Cellular: Offers wide coverage, capable of providing service across cities, regions, and even countries. The range is extended through a network of interconnected cell towers.
    • WiFi: Typically limited to a short range, usually around 20-30 meters indoors. Its range is limited to the area around the wireless access point (router).
  • Data Speed:
    • Cellular: Speed varies depending on the generation of network technology (3G, 4G, 5G, etc.). Newer generations like 5G offer higher speeds and lower latency.
    • WiFi: Generally offers faster data speeds within its limited range. Speed can be influenced by factors like the specific WiFi standard (e.g., 802.11ac, 802.11ax), router quality, and interference.
  • Connectivity:
    • Cellular: Provides wider, continuous connectivity suitable for mobile communication and services requiring broad coverage
    • WiFi: Best suited for stationary or limited-mobility use, such as in homes, offices, or public hotspots. It's ideal for devices that don't require mobility, like smart home devices.
  • Use Cases:
    • Cellular: Widely used for mobile phones, IoT devices with a need for broad coverage, and in areas where WiFi is not available.
    • WiFi: Commonly used for internet browsing, streaming, and connecting multiple devices in homes and offices.
  • Cost and Infrastructure:
    • Cellular: Requires extensive infrastructure like cell towers and is often more expensive for the end-user, typically involving data plans and contracts.
    • WiFi: Involves lower operational costs, with many public hotspots available for free. Home and office setups require a router and an internet subscription.
  • Security:
    • Cellular: Generally offers strong security features, with encrypted communication and authentication protocols managed by service providers.
    • WiFi: Can be less secure if not properly configured. Vulnerable to various attacks if encryption standards like WPA2 or WPA3 are not used.

 

If I summarize this in tabular format, it goes like this.

Feature

Cellular Communication

WiFi Communication

Technology Basis

Cellular network with allocated frequencies; divided into cells each served by a base station

Uses IEEE 802.11 standards; operates mainly on 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz frequencies

Range and Coverage

Wide coverage; service across cities and countries

Short range; typically around 20-30 meters indoors

Data Speed

Varies by network generation (3G, 4G, 5G); newer generations offer higher speeds

Generally faster within its range; influenced by WiFi standard and router quality

Connectivity

Continuous connectivity; suitable for mobile and broad coverage needs

Best for stationary use; limited-mobility applications

Use Cases

Mobile phones, IoT devices, areas without WiFi

Internet browsing, streaming, home and office networks

Cost and Infrastructure

Extensive infrastructure; more expensive with data plans

Lower operational costs; requires a router and internet subscription

Security

Strong security with encrypted communication

Can be less secure if not configured properly

Differents in Protocol Design

When comparing cellular communication with WiFi communication, focusing on their respective radio protocol stacks reveals significant differences in their design and operation. The radio protocol stack is a crucial component in defining how these technologies handle communication over wireless networks. the radio protocol stacks of cellular and WiFi communications are tailored to their specific applications and environments. Cellular technologies feature a more complex and robust stack designed for wide-area, mobile communication with strong emphasis on continuity, security, and QoS. In contrast, WiFi's stack is simpler, focusing on short-range, high-bandwidth communication with limited mobility and QoS features. Both stacks have evolved to meet the demands of modern wireless communication, with cellular moving towards 5G technologies and WiFi advancing with standards like 802.11ax.

NOTE : If you are interested in this topic for engineering common sense, just read the high level descriptions here, but if you are seriously interested in this topic and engage in this area as a job, I would strongly suggest you to go through the detailed pages linked here.

  • Layered Architecture:
    • Cellular (3GPP e.g., LTE, 5G):
      • Physical Layer (PHY): Modulates and demodulates signals, handles data transfer over the radio frequency spectrum. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE PHY Frame DL, 4G/LTE PHY Frame UL, 5G/NR PHY Frame
      • Data Link Layer: Split into two sub-layers: Media Access Control (MAC) and Radio Link Control (RLC). MAC handles multiplexing of data streams, while RLC ensures data delivery. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE MAC, 4G/LTE RLC, 5G/NR MAC, 5G/NR RLC
      • Network Layer and Above 
        • PDCP: Packet Data Convergence Protocol (PDCP) layer, responsible for IP data encapsulation and header compression. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE PDCP, 5G/NR PDCP
        • RRC and Above: Radio Resource Control (RRC) layer manages control signaling between the mobile device and the network. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE Fullstack, 5G/NR Fullstack
    • WiFi (IEEE 802.11):
      • Physical Layer (PHY): Similar to cellular, it deals with modulation and demodulation over the 2.4 GHz or 5 GHz bands. Check these out for further details : WiFi PHY frames
      • Data Link Layer: Also split into two sub-layers: Logical Link Control (LLC) and Media Access Control (MAC). LLC handles protocol multiplexing, while MAC deals with channel access, error checking, and frame sequencing. Check these out for further details : WiFi MAC frames
      • Network Layer and Above: Generally not defined in WiFi as it is in cellular; WiFi is typically agnostic to network-layer protocols like IP.
  • Radio Access Technologies (RAT):
    • Cellular: Employs various RATs like GSM, WCDMA, LTE, and NR (New Radio for 5G). These technologies are designed for wide-area coverage and support mobility at high speeds.
    • WiFi: Primarily uses DSSS and Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM) and, in newer standards like Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax), OFDMA. Designed for short-range, high-bandwidth communication.
  • Mobility Management:
    • Cellular: Includes robust mobility management protocols to handle handovers between cells and towers, ensuring continuous connectivity. There are various procedures handling mobility situations in cellular, like cell reselection, measurement report, handover etc. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE Multicell
    • WiFi: Limited mobility management, primarily focused on handovers between different WiFi access points without the need for seamless continuity.
  • Quality of Service (QoS):
    • Cellular: Advanced QoS mechanisms are integrated into the protocol stack, essential for voice and data services. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE QoS, 5G/NR QoS
    • WiFi: QoS is supported (e.g., Wi-Fi Multimedia (WMM) in 802.11e), but it is generally less sophisticated compared to cellular. Check these out for further details : WiFi QoS
  • Security Protocols:
  • Spectrum Utilization:
    • Cellular: Utilizes licensed spectrum bands, allowing for controlled and optimized usage for better coverage and reliability. Check these out for further details : 4G/LTE Band/Frequency, 4G/LTE BandWidth, 5G/NR Band/Frequency
    • WiFi: Operates in unlicensed spectrum bands, which can lead to interference and variability in performance.

YouTube

Refernces